William Orf: I've had a garden railroad for over 20 years using brass track and ONE electrical connection point for over 500 feet of LGB track. Once a year I sand the rails with #600 grit sandpaper and then touch them up with a track-cleaning car. Last year I decided to purchase AristoCraft stainless track for the sections of my gaden railroad that corrode most. In one year, sections of the Aristo track are RUSTED quite a bit. I've been too busy to take the sections back out, put in other brass sections, box the stainless up, send them back, and see what happens next. But I'm surprised and disappointed. So as for me, brass is the best I've used and proven.

Willie Horn: I use brass track. I started out with LGB but it was so high I started using Aristo brass track for my garden trains. After three years out side the Aristo track is brittle and falling apart. I am having to replace the ties with LGB ties because LGB ties seem to handled the sun better. I wish I had just paid the higher price and stayed with LGB.